600-Mhz-compressedThe US Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is about to embark on the next phase of one of the most complicated and far-reaching auctions in history. The Broadcast Incentive Auction seeks to repurpose the beachfront spectrum in the 600 MHz band from television use to wireless use. The Incentive Auction may ultimately make available up to 126 MHz of valuable wireless airwaves for exciting new 5G services. However, Incentive Auction participants need to make sure that potential post-auction interference concerns are identified and properly addressed.

The Incentive Auction is really two auctions: a Reverse Auction and a Forward Auction. The Reverse Auction is where eligible TV licensees will have the opportunity to voluntarily return some or all of their spectrum usage rights in exchange for a share of the proceeds from the Forward Auction. The Forward Auction is where the FCC will sell new licenses to use the repurposed spectrum for mobile broadband services.

At the conclusion of the Reverse Auction, the FCC will attempt a complex repacking of the TV stations into the spectrum below TV channel 30 (566 MHz). The success of this repacking in freeing up spectrum for the Forward Auction will depend on how many TV stations decide to relinquish their spectrum.

One interesting aspect of this auction is that the ultimate band plan in any given market will actually depend on how many TV stations are repacked in and around the market. Thus, band plans may likely be different across markets. These band plan incongruities set up a potential for interference between TV stations and new wireless licensees. The FCC calls this interference potential an “impairment.”

The FCC has actually modeled this repacking effort considering how many TV stations have indicated their intention to participate in the Reverse Auction. One of the FCC’s goals here was to determine the potential number of impairments so Forward Auction participants can develop informed bidding strategies. While the FCC has tried to minimize impairments, we won’t know exactly how many there are or where they are until after the Reverse Auction is over and repacking has been completed.

Forward Auction participants may want to model the potential impact of impairments on their bidding and deployment strategies before, during and after the Forward Auction, especially as TV stations are repacked. Comsearch’s TVclear services and software tools can determine impairment impacts and help Forward Auction participants develop informed strategies.

The Broadcast Incentive Auction is the most complex spectrum auction ever conducted. Nonetheless, interference impairments can possibly cause buyer’s remorse. Knowing the location and magnitude of impairments will help Forward Auction participants bid smartly.

About the Author

Mark Gibson

With close to 30 years of spectrum management experience, Mark Gibson is responsible for developing domestic and international business opportunities for Comsearch, a CommScope company. In addition to leading Comsearch’s business development efforts for AWS, 700 MHz and TV white space products and services, he has led efforts to address spectrum sharing between the federal government and commercial users. Mark has authored several papers on spectrum sharing and relocation and has advised numerous wireless participants in their system design. He has spoken worldwide on spectrum management and related issues. Mark earned a bachelor of science in electrical engineering from the University of Maryland.

See all posts by this author

Comments

3 comments for "Watch Out For Impairments! The 600 MHz Incentive Auction"
Rikin Thakker Friday, June 10, 2016 3:26 PM

Very good insight, Mark!

John Schilberg Friday, October 14, 2016 7:29 PM

Mark, Thank you for the nicely written explanation of "Impairment" related to the FCC's TV spectrum auction.

Mark Gibson Monday, October 17, 2016 12:49 PM

John - thanks for the feedback. Looks like the FCC is trying to keep a consistent band plan across all markets, so we'll see what they end up with...stay tuned!

Add Your Comment

Please submit your comment using the form below

 
(required)